In the book, the current head of the indie brewery says something profound...
"As you get bigger, you get more average." -Archibald Gack
How many times have we seen that the biggest company in our industry is really making quite average products? (Put your shoes back on. You don't need to count them all.)
Contrast that statement with this one said by a customer in an indie retailer.
"They must be the best because you see them everywhere." -unknown customer
Customer perception is since a product is everywhere it must be the best. The reality is more often than not, the products sold everywhere are really quite average. There is better stuff out there.
This begs two questions...
- Do you differentiate yourself by not carrying the most popular item in the category, thus flying in the face of customer perception?
- Do you carry the popular items to draw the traffic and then try to upsell to the better items?
Both strategies can work, but they each work with a different crowd.
Use the first if you only want to go after the innovators and early adopters, the people who only want the best. They are a small market, but they pay top dollar to be first or to have the best. You can make a lot of money off of them as long as you stay at the top of the market and as long as you continually advertise your cutting edge expertise.
Use the second if you want to go for the early and late majority. They are a much larger crowd, but they have more options to find what they want. And usually what they want has been commoditized so your margins on the everywhere items will be smaller and your profit will be based on your ability to upsell.
The markets are different for each of these strategies. Know which one you're in so that you'll know who you're trying to attract.
PS You can trying being in both categories. Unfortunately, the message usually gets lost in advertising. When you advertise the popular items, you lose the innovator crowd. When you advertise the innovative items, you lose the popular crowd. That's why it is better to pick one and do it better than anyone else.